Benny Scarpetta's: Savor the Best Pizza in Lynchburg!

Excellent New York style pizza. The size of the 28 inch pizza is worth the price in sheer shock and awe value. Lol

Benny’s, in my opinion, is the best pizza spot in Lynchburg. They always got unique options for a slice of pizza on top of your regular cheese, pepperoni. The inside has a really cool aesthetic, great place just to hangout as well. Pizza always tastes amazing.

I love their enormous slices! It is amazing how big they are for such a small price! And the pepperoni is always perfectly cooked! The staff is always friendly and helpful. And to make the place even better they’ve added pinball and centipede and miss Pac-Man! I could literally spend my whole day going back in time to my teens dropping 20 bucks on centipede! Great family friendly place.

Food was amazing! Best customer service I had in a while. I highly recommend this pizzeria to everyone of all ages.

Edit: late 12/24 After a long hiatus I decided to give Benny’s another shot and the Versace is a killer slice. Besides the bruschetta this is my favorite special they offer. Compared to many of the others these two are more conducive to a slice. Benny’s casual atmosphere and the ability to grab a quick slice to go has always made it an attractive option. It’s simple, to the point pizza with specials to jazz things up. When done right it’s a great slice for $5-6 That said, after my last few visits the quality has taken a hit overall and the specials don’t seem to have the same effort as before. It’s been disappointing but I’m still willing to give them another shot

Huge slices. We got a bruschetta and a sausage slice. Its pizza…but big. Nice NY style crust— thin, chewy. Worth the drive into town

Definitely should have taken pictures but my hands are full, their signature pizza was so large that it actually had to go in the hatch of my vehicle and had to be tilted to make it through the front door of my home which is hilarious and wonderful. The pizza is delicious and crisp if you reheat it in a frying pan for about 3 to 4 minutes and then splash a tablespoon of water and put a lid on top you'll have a crispy bottom crust and a soft upper crust and bubbly cheese. Highly recommend

I had no idea that the slices or whole pies were this huge! I had to transport the pizza in my trunk. A slice is so big that it hung over the plate. The taste is unique from other chains in the area, and the crust is delicious. I was satisfied with my first experience and will recommend it if you're looking for great pizza. The price point of $36 is not bad for the size, and you can actually cut the huge slices into smaller slices if you choose.